Healthy living · Bread
White, wholegrain or sourdough: which bread is better?
Bread is on our table every day. Scientists say how it is made matters more than the label.
- Good sourdough is healthy for most people, but bad sourdough is no better than other bread.
- Most supermarket bread is ultra-processed and made from refined flour.
- People's blood sugar reacts very differently to the same bread.
Who says what?
TS
Tim SpectorKing's College London · ZOE
"It depends how you make it so, good sourdough bread is healthy for most people."
He goes on: "Bad sourdough bread is probably as unhealthy as other bread." He also says most supermarket bread is ultra processed. ZOE podcast, "Can bread be healthy?"
CG
Christopher GardnerStanford Medicine, nutrition
"The solution to getting enough fiber is simple: eat more whole foods"
In the same piece he says we eat far too much refined flour, as in white sliced bread. Fortune, 18.01.2017
ES
Eran SegalWeizmann Institute computational biologist
"There were no clinically significant differences between the effects of these two types of bread"
Comparing industrial white bread with wholewheat sourdough. The differences were between people. Cell Press, 06.06.2017
Where they disagree
SpectorWell-made sourdough is a healthy choice.
SegalOn average no difference was found between white bread and sourdough; the difference was from person to person.
Try it this week
- Pick bread with a short ingredient list: flour, water, salt, starter.
- Swap some of your white bread for wholegrain.
For fresh bread and breakfast:
Cafés and bakeries in Baku →
Cafés and bakeries in Baku →
CoffeeWhen should you drink your morning coffee?SweetsPakhlava and sweet tea: after a meal or on their own?SleepLate dinner: how long before bed should you stop eating?OilsIs sunflower oil bad for you? Scientists answerHabitsAfter a heavy meal, walk for 10 minutes
Sources: ZOE podcast, "Can bread be healthy?" · Fortune, Christopher Gardner, "These 3 food myths could be hurting your health" (18.01.2017) · Cell Press release on Korem et al., Cell Metabolism, 2017 (PMID 28591632). This article is not medical advice.